Philosophy and Political Agency in the Writings of Frederick II of Prussia
June 2021
|
Journal article
|
The Historical Journal
Frederick II’s writings have conventionally been viewed either as political tools or as means of public self-fashioning – part of his campaign to raise the status of Prussia from middling principality to great power. This article, by contrast, argues that Frederick’s works must also be taken seriously on their own terms, and interpreted against the background of Enlightenment philosophy. Frederick’s notions of kingship and state service were not governed mostly by a principle of pure morality or 'humanitarianism', as argued influentially by Friedrich Meinecke. On the contrary, the king's views were part and parcel of an eighteenth-century vision of modern kingship in commercial society, based on the benign pursuit of self-love and luxury. A close analysis of Frederick's writings demonstrates that authorial labour was integral to his political agency, publicly placing constraints on what could be perceived as legitimate conduct, rather than mere intellectual window-dressing or an Enlightened pastime in irresolvable tension with his politics.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0018246X20000473
Jüdische und christliche Intellektuelle in Berlin um 1800
May 2021
|
Book
Die jüdische Selbstemanzipation des 18. Jahrhunderts (Haskala) ist in der neueren Aufklärungsforschung zu einem zentralen Thema avanciert. Buchtitel wie 'Cultural Revolution in Berlin: Jews in the Age of Enlightenment' sind bezeichnend dafür. Der vorliegende Band, der auf eine Konferenz im Jüdischen Museum Berlin im Jahr 2016 zurückgeht, ergänzt das komplexe Bild dieses Umbruchs um einen in der Regel unterschätzten Aspekt – nämlich die um 1800 reich dokumentierte Symbiose zwischen jüdischen und christlichen Intellektuellen der Stadt. In ihrer Vielgestaltigkeit geht sie weit über den kanonisch gewordenen Fall Lessing/Moses Mendelssohn hinaus. Ihr Antrieb war das beidseitige Wunschbild einer jüdischen Mitbürgerschaft nicht nur in rechtlicher, sondern auch kultureller Hinsicht. Im Aktionsraum dieses doppelten Lernprozesses, den die 14 Fallstudien des Bandes entfalten, finden sich neben Namen, die man kennt – wie David Friedländer, Salomon Maimon und Rahel Levin bzw. Friedrich Nicolai, Karl Philipp Moritz und Wilhelm von Humboldt – auch relativ unbekannte, die es sich lohnt weiter zu beforschen. Umso mehr, als das symbiotische Experiment Berlin 1800 offensichtlich die Basis für den in der Welt singulären jüdischen Beitrag zur deutschsprachigen Kultur bis 1933 war.
https://www.wehrhahn-verlag.de/public/index.php?ID_Section=1&ID_Product=1422
Thomas Abbt and Moses Mendelssohn: Private Correspondence and Public Exchange at the Origins of Phädon
May 2021
|
Chapter
|
Jüdische und christliche Intellektuelle in Berlin um 1800
The first modern English collection of a wide range of Frederick the Great's philosophical works.
https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691176420/frederick-the-greats-philosophical-writings
Un culte universaliste de la raison? Réflexions sur les Lumières, l’universalisme et les particularismes culturels
October 2020
|
Chapter
|
The Epoch of Universalism / L’époque de l’universalisme: 1769-1989
https://www.degruyter.com/view/title/575134
The Book of Job and the Sex Life of Elephants: The Limits of Evidential Credibility in Eighteenth-Century Natural History and Biblical Criticism
December 2019
|
Journal article
|
Journal of Modern History
Laureate of the 2020 James L. Clifford Prize of the American Society for Eighteenth-Century Studies (ASECS) for the best article on an 18th-century topic across all disciplines.
https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/journals/jmh/pr/130420
From the civic improvement of the Jews to the separation of state and church: Languages of reform in Brandenburg-Prussia, 1781-1799
November 2019
|
Chapter
|
Languages of Reform in the Eighteenth Century: When Europe Lost Its Fear of Change
The chapter compares the debate over Christian Wilhelm Dohm’s call for the ‘civic improvement’ of the Jews (Über die bürgerliche Verbesserung der Juden, 1781) to a discussion of a proposal for confessional union between the Jewish and Protestant communities in Berlin (1799), thereby highlighting the changing languages of political reform in Brandenburg-Prussia from the early 1780s to c. 1800. Various contemporary conceptions of the interrelationship between the state and religious associations are examined; particular attention is dedicated to works by Dohm, Moses Mendelssohn, Wilhelm von Humboldt, David Friedländer, and Friedrich Schleiermacher.
https://www.routledge.com/Languages-of-Reform-in-the-Eighteenth-Century-When-Europe-Lost-Its-Fear/Richter-Maissen-Albertone/p/book/9780367427733
Les concours de l’Académie de Berlin, vecteurs de transferts intellectuels franco-allemands 1745-1786
November 2019
|
Chapter
|
Les échanges savants franco-allemands au XVIIIe siècle: transferts, circulations et réseaux
Dans la seconde moitié du XVIIIe siècle, l’Académie des sciences et belles-lettres de Berlin fut un pivot des échanges et transferts intellectuels au sein de l’Europe francophone et germanophone. Elle ne fut pas seulement l’unique institution royale majeure à englober les sciences naturelles, les mathématiques, la philosophie spéculative et la littérature. En raison des options culturelles de Frédéric II et de la présence d’une importante communauté huguenote à Berlin, l’Académie mena ses travaux principalement en français. Toutefois, malgré la prédilection linguistique du roi, l’Académie de Berlin ne fut pas un bastion français dans le Brandebourg-Prusse. Elle stimula des transferts multilatéraux et réciproques, comme je le démontre en étudiant les questions mises au concours par l’institution sous le règne de Frédéric II. Si le prix annuel fut parfois décerné à des auteurs français de premier plan, l’Académie reconnut aussi fréquemment l’originalité d’intellectuels allemands – diffusant leurs ouvrages et leur valeur au lectorat francophone dans toute l’Europe.
http://www.pur-editions.fr/detail.php?idOuv=4920
Organizing Enlightenment: Information Overload and the Invention of the Modern Research University, written by Chad Wellmon
May 2018
|
Other
|
Erudition and the Republic of Letters
43 History, Heritage and Archaeology, 4303 Historical Studies, 35 Commerce, Management, Tourism and Services
Forum: The German Enlightenment
November 2017
|
Journal article
|
German History
The term Enlightenment (or Aufklärung) remains heavily contested. Even when historians delimit the remit of the concept, assigning it to a particular historical period rather than to an intellectual or moral programme, the public resonance of the Enlightenment remains high and problematic—especially when equated in an essentialist manner with modernity or some core values of ‘the West’. This Forum has been convened to discuss recent research on the Enlightenment in Germany, different views of the term and its ideological use in public discourse outside academia.
http://doi.org/10.1093/gerhis/ghx104
Lessing’s Laocoon and Enlightenment semiotics
September 2017
|
Chapter
|
Rethinking Lessing’s Laocoon: Antiquity, Enlightenment, and the ‘Limits’ of Painting and Poetry
In Laocoon, Lessing attempts to cast the poet as ‘elevating’ arbitrary linguistic signs to the status of the natural signs of painting. This chapter sets out to explore the seeming paradox of this position. It argues that Lessing drew upon a wide range of French and German thinkers who downplayed the arbitrariness of language while simultaneously emphasizing its natural features (among them, Rousseau’s projection of a performative ‘language of signs’ on to classical antiquity, Condillac’s ‘language of action’, and not least Diderot’s musings on what he termed ‘poetic hieroglyphs’). The essay consequently demonstrates how the Laocoon takes its inspiration from multiple sources, extending far beyond the intellectual remit of Christian Wolff and his German followers: Lessing’s call for the naturalization of arbitrary signs, and his discussion of ancient poetry in this light, can only be understood against the backdrop of a cross-European debate about linguistic signs.
https://global.oup.com/academic/product/rethinking-lessings-laocoon-9780198802228
Rethinking Lessing's Laocoon from across the Humanities
September 2017
|
Chapter
|
Rethinking Lessing's Laocoon: Antiquity, Enlightenment, and the 'Limits' of Painting and Poetry
The introduction sketches the scope (and some of the Classical debts) of Lessing’s Laocoon and reassess its legacy on the occasion of its 250th anniversary. It outlines Lessing’s arguments about the 'limits’ (Grenzen) of poetry and painting, while situating Lessing’s project within Enlightenment ideas about the Classical past and contemporary aesthetic criticism. The editors also lay out the overall purpose of the volume, explaining why a cross-disciplinary approach to Lessing's Laocoon is necessary today.
https://global.oup.com/academic/product/rethinking-lessings-laocoon-9780198802228
Rethinking Lessing's Laocoon: Antiquity, Enlightenment, and the 'Limits' of Painting and Poetry
September 2017
|
Book
Gotthold Ephraim Lessing first published Laokoon, oder uber die Grenzen der Mahlerey und Poesie (Laocoon, or on the Limits of Painting and Poetry) in 1766. Over the last 250 years, Lessing's essay has exerted an incalculable influence on western critical thinking. Not only has it directed the history of post-Enlightenment aesthetics, it has also shaped the very practices of 'poetry' and 'painting' in a myriad of different ways.
In this anthology of specially commissioned chapters - comprising the first ever edited book on the Laocoon in English - a range of leading critical voices has been brought together to reassess Lessing's essay on its 250th anniversary. Combining perspectives from multiple disciplines (including classics, intellectual history, philosophy, aesthetics, media studies, comparative literature, and art history), the book explores the Laocoon from a plethora of critical angles. Chapters discuss Lessing's interpretation of ancient art and poetry, the cultural backdrops of the eighteenth century, and the validity of the Laocoon's observations in the fields of aesthetics, semiotics, and philosophy. The volume shows how the Laocoon exploits Greek and Roman models to sketch the proper spatial and temporal 'limits' (Grenzen) of what Lessing called 'poetry' and 'painting'; at the same time it demonstrates how Lessing's essay is embedded within Enlightenment theories of art, perception, and historical interpretation, as well as within nascent eighteenth-century ideas about the 'scientific' study of Classical antiquity (Altertumswissenschaft). To engage critically with the Laocoon, and to make sense of its legacy over the last 250 years, consequently involves excavating various 'classical presences': by looking back to the Graeco-Roman past, the volume demonstrates, Lessing forged a whole new tradition of modern aesthetics.
https://global.oup.com/academic/product/rethinking-lessings-laocoon-9780198802228
Enlightenment, Lessing, Gotthold Ephraim, Image theory, Narrative, Word and image, 18th century, German Enlightenment, Art theory, Time and space
Review of Andreas Pečar, Die Masken des Königs. Friedrich II. von Preußen als Schriftsteller (Frankfurt: Campus, 2015)
April 2017
|
Other
|
Research Center Sanssouci (RECS) website
Between Friedrich Meinecke and Ernst Cassirer: Isaiah Berlin’s Bifurcated Enlightenment
October 2016
|
Chapter
|
Isaiah Berlin and the Enlightenment
<p style="text-align:justify;">This chapter explores the hitherto neglected influence of Friedrich Meinecke on Isaiah Berlin’s distinction between a mostly French Enlightenment and its alleged rivals in Germany. Highlighting the structural and terminological similarities between Berlin’s account of the Counter-Enlightenment and Meinecke’s description of the precursors of historicism, it also provides as yet unpublished evidence from Berlin’s correspondence to this effect. Berlin’s endorsement of Meinecke’s dichotomy between Enlightenment and pre-historicism is situated against his distaste for attempts to reveal cross-currents and common themes in eighteenth-century thought. This aversion to the study of transnational links in the Enlightenment is manifest in Berlin’s hostile reaction to Ernst Cassirer’s work on the topic.</p>
Meinecke, Hegel, SBTMR, historicism, Cassirer, Deutsche Bewegung
How to do things with signs: Rousseau’s ancient performative idiom
October 2016
|
Journal article
|
History of Political Thought
In various works, Jean-Jacques Rousseau ascribes to the ancient Greeks, Romans, and Israelites a mostly visual, gestural, and non-semantic idiom of communication: the language of signs. The article examines the performative aspects of this imagined ancient language, while situating it within the context of other eighteenth-century projections of a vivid language of action onto classical antiquity. It is argued that Rousseau’s originality lies not only in his emphasis on the performative rather than merely passionate character of this idiom. He also weaved it into a typology of political regimes and performance arts, identifying it with a particular kind of republican politics and public festivals. More generally, the language of signs assisted Rousseau in explaining the establishment of national polities by legendary lawgivers, as well as in fathoming the transformation of human nature in the transition from a state of nature to civil society.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/26228685
Rousseau's Imagined Antiquity: An Introduction
October 2016
|
Journal article
|
History of Political Thought
https://www.jstor.org/stable/26228682
Tim Blanning, Frederick the Great: King of Prussia
October 2016
|
Other
|
European History Quarterly
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
Engaging with Rousseau: Reaction and Interpretation from the Eighteenth Century to the Present
July 2016
|
Book
Jean-Jacques Rousseau has been cast as a champion of Enlightenment and a beacon of Romanticism, a father figure of radical revolutionaries and totalitarian dictators alike, an inventor of the modern notion of the self, and an advocate of stern ancient republicanism. Engaging with Rousseau treats his writings as an enduring topic of debate, examining the diverse responses they have attracted from the Enlightenment to the present. Such notions as the general will were, for example, refracted through very different prisms during the struggle for independence in Latin America and in social conflicts in Eastern Europe, or modified by thinkers from Kant to contemporary political theorists. Beyond Rousseau's ideas, his public image too travelled around the world. This book examines engagement with Rousseau's works as well as with his self-fashioning; especially in turbulent times, his defiant public identity and his call for regeneration were admired or despised by intellectuals and political agents.
https://www.cambridge.org/gb/academic/subjects/history/history-ideas-and-intellectual-history/engaging-rousseau-reaction-and-interpretation-eighteenth-century-present?format=PB
Philosophy
Adrastus versus Diogenes: Frederick the Great and Jean-Jacques Rousseau on self-love
July 2016
|
Chapter
|
Engaging with Rousseau: Reaction and Interpretation from the Eighteenth Century to the Present
The essay examines the intellectual relationship between Frederick II (‘the Great’) of Prussia and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, which has been overshadowed by the much-advertised collaboration between Voltaire and the self-styled ‘philosopher-king’. Though in this case one cannot find a close alliance, Frederick’s works and his correspondence betray a long-lasting fascination with the themes raised by Rousseau in his Discourses of the 1750s. Their mutual fascination reached its peak in 1762 when Rousseau sought refuge in the Prussian enclave of Neuchâtel following the outcry prompted by Emile and the Social Contract. The essay investigates the notion of self-love or amour propre in letters exchanged between Frederick and Rousseau through George Keith, the governor of Neuchâtel, as well as in Frederick’s poems and treatises. While both Rousseau and Frederick used an amalgam of Stoic and Epicurean elements in their discussions of self-love, the king identified Rousseau as a modern champion of virtue as self-denial. It is argued that despite such disagreements, there was much common ground between Frederick’s notion of self-love and Rousseau’s modified views, especially as elaborated in Émile.
https://www.cambridge.org/gb/academic/subjects/history/history-ideas-and-intellectual-history/engaging-rousseau-reaction-and-interpretation-eighteenth-century-present?format=PB
An Epicurean democracy in language: the volte face in Johann David Michaelis’s early career
June 2016
|
Chapter
|
Life Forms in the Thinking of the Long Eighteenth Century
https://toronto.degruyter.com/view/title/527719
Review of László Kontler, Translations, Histories, Enlightenments: William Robertson in Germany, 1760–1795 (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014)
The arbitrariness of the linguistic sign: variations on an Enlightenment theme
October 2012
|
Journal article
|
Journal of the History of Ideas: an international quarterly devoted to intellectual history
https://www.jstor.org/stable/23353978
Language and Enlightenment: The Berlin Debates of the Eighteenth Century
September 2012
|
Book
What is the role of language in human cognition? Could we attain self-consciousness and construct our civilization without language? Such were the questions at the basis of eighteenth-century debates on the joint evolution of language, mind, and culture. Language and Enlightenment highlights the importance of language in the social theory, epistemology, and aesthetics of the Enlightenment. While focusing on the Berlin Academy under Frederick the Great, Avi Lifschitz situates the Berlin debates within a larger temporal and geographical framework. He argues that awareness of the historicity and linguistic rootedness of all forms of life was a mainstream Enlightenment notion rather than a feature of the so-called 'Counter-Enlightenment'.
Enlightenment authors of different persuasions investigated whether speechless human beings could have developed their language and society on their own. Such inquiries usually pondered the difficult shift from natural signs like cries and gestures to the artificial, articulate words of human language. This transition from nature to artifice was mirrored in other domains of inquiry, such as the origins of social relations, inequality, the arts, and the sciences. By examining a wide variety of authors - Leibniz, Wolff, Condillac, Rousseau, Michaelis, and Herder, among others - Language and Enlightenment emphasises the open and malleable character of the eighteenth-century Republic of Letters. The language debates demonstrate that German theories of culture and language were not merely a rejection of French ideas. New notions of the genius of language and its role in cognition were constructed through a complex interaction with cross-European currents, especially via the prize contests at the Berlin Academy.
https://global.oup.com/academic/product/language-and-enlightenment-9780198777649
Rousseau 300: Nature, Self and State
January 2012
|
Exhibition
Curated with UCL Art Collections, this exhibition featured rare items from UCL’s Book Collections to mark the 300th anniversary of the birth of one of the most controversial authors in the history of philosophy, Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778).
Featuring first editions of Rousseau’s works, including On the Social Contract (Du contrat social, 1762), frontispieces and translations, the display highlighted his unique and interdisciplinary characteristics as a philosopher who not only wrote on politics, economics and education, but also composed music and wrote best-selling novels.
A collaboration with UCL Centre for Transnational History, the British Museum and the Voltaire Foundation, the accompanying public programme included an international conference marking Rousseau’s tercentenary and a special performance of his rarely produced opera Le Devin du village by UCL Opera Club.
https://www.ucl.ac.uk/culture/projects/rousseau-300-nature-self-and-state-2012
The Enlightenment’s ‘experimental metaphysics’: inquiries into the origins and history of language
Eighteenth-century Epicureanism is often viewed as radical, anti-religious and politically dangerous. But to what extent does this simplify the ancient philosophy and underestimate its significance in Enlightenment writing?
Through a pan-European analysis of Enlightenment centres from Scotland to Russia via the Netherlands, France and Germany, contributors argue that elements of classical Epicureanism were appropriated by radical and conservative writers alike. They move beyond literature and political theory to examine the application of Epicurean ideas in domains as diverse as physics, natural law, and the philosophy of language, drawing on the work of both major figures (Diderot, Hélvetius, Smith and Hume) and of lesser-known but equally influential thinkers (Johann Jacob Schmauss and Dmitrii Anichkov). This unique collaboration, bringing together historians, philosophers, political scientists and literary scholars, provides rich and varied insights into the different strategic uses of Epicureanism in the eighteenth century.
From the corruption of French to the cultural distinctiveness of German: the controversy over Prémontval’s Préservatif (1759)
August 2007
|
Journal article
|
Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century
Review of Ursula Goldenbaum (ed.), Appell an das Publikum. Die öffentliche Debatte in der deutschen Aufklärung 1687-1796 (Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 2004), 2 vols
July 2006
|
Other
|
German Historical Institute London Bulletin
Language as the key to the epistemological labyrinth: Turgot’s changing view of human perception
October 2004
|
Journal article
|
Historiographia Linguistica: international journal for the history of the language