Revolution and the rule of law: Dicey on Irish Home Rule
January 2024
|
Chapter
|
Dicey + 100. Albert Venn Dicey: A Centennial Commemoration
Dicey came close to acknowledging a legitimate right to separatist revolution for Ireland but rejected Home Rule as an illegitimate attempt to revolutionist the British constitution.
unionism, Ireland, Dicey, Home Rule, revolution
How revolutionary was the “Irish Revolution”?
September 2021
|
Journal article
|
Eire-Ireland
FFR
Northern Ireland and the Far Left, c. 1965 – 1975
October 2018
|
Journal article
|
Contemporary British History
The far left, defined as those to the left of orthodox communism, with few but important exceptions defined the Northern Ireland Troubles in essentially republican terms as a struggle to complete Irish national self-determination. Despite this lack of independent orientation, far left ideas fertilised both republicanism and loyalism in the 1970s. They are an important element in understanding the dynamics of ideological conflict in the period.
International Marxist Group, Sinn Fein, Militant Tendency, Socialist Workers Party, Socialist Labour League, British and Irish Communist Organisation
The Murderer of Warren Street The True Story of a Nineteenth-Century Revolutionary
May 2018
|
Book
The true story of one of nineteenth-century London’s most notorious murderers.
Biography & Autobiography
How it began, what might have been? Political memoirs of Northern Ireland in the 1960s
April 2018
|
Journal article
|
Irish Political Studies
Irish Labour and the 'Co-operative Commonwealth' in the era of the First World War
February 2018
|
Chapter
|
Labour, British radicalism and the First World War
An Impatient Life: A Memoir, by Daniel Bensaïd, tr. David Ferbach
August 2016
|
Journal article
|
The English Historical Review
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
Land War Homicides
June 2016
|
Chapter
|
Uncertain Futures Essays about the Irish Past for Roy Foster
"Bibliography of the major writings of Roy Foster to 2014"--Pages 283-289.
How to make a revolution: the historical and political writings of Raymond Postgate
May 2016
|
Journal article
|
Socialist History Journal
I came across the work Raymond Postgate (1896-1971) because he wrote about the kinds of things I am interested in: labour history, the history of the left, revolutions, and Ireland. What I found particularly attractive, however, was his writing style. Postgate was a skilled journalist and editor. He knew how to grab the reader. This is evident in the large survey history he wrote with GDH Cole in 1938, The Common People. The first pages of this book, in which Postgate depicts the final destruction of the old world with the defeat of the clans at Culluden, is a masterpiece of evocation and drama. Following on hard is a tour of Great Britain mapping out the social and economic conditions of the people in 1750. Here the hand of GDH Cole is evident. One feels it would be less laborious to undertake the journey by foot. The Common People is often discussed as though Cole wrote the substance while Postgate applied the decoration. Certainly Postgate added much of the style that made it a bestseller, but his analysis is evident throughout.
Revolution And The Whip Of Reaction: Technicians Of Power And The Dialectic Of Radicalisation
February 2016
|
Journal article
|
Journal of Historical Sociology
This article argues that sociologically informed studies of revolution tend to underestimate the importance of counter-revolution and ‘reaction’ in generating radicalisation. Revolutions are inherently political. Most accounts recognise this, but emphasise the executive organs of state – such as monarch, cabinet or ministers – at the expense of the intermediary ‘technicians of power’. Revolutions, however, typically seek to refashion an entire technocracy of power, and in so doing struggle against embedded and powerful sites of reaction. Central to the dynamic of revolution is the ‘purge’ of the technocracy of power. As governing structures are not easily transformed at a stroke, revolutions may be seen as punctuating long processes of struggle. Historically, the governing apparatus has been most effectively revolutionised under conditions of military occupation. The thesis is illustrated here by a narrative of revolution in Europe from the English Civil War to the Liberation of the 1940s, with a coda on ’68.
POLITICAL VIOLENCE
January 2016
|
Chapter
|
PRINCETON HISTORY OF MODERN IRELAND
Mo Moulton, Ireland and the Irish in Interwar England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014). Pages viii + 378. £65.00 hardback.
December 2015
|
Journal article
|
Continuity and Change
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
'Marxists of Strict Observance'? The Second International, National Defence, and the Question of War
June 2015
|
Journal article
|
Historical Journal
In August 1914, as war broke out, socialist parties across Europe offered support to their own governments. The Socialist International was shattered. This rush to defencism has traditionally been seen as a volte face in which the International's frequent protestations in favour of peace and international working-class solidarity were suddenly abandoned. The collapse has been variously ascribed to socialist helplessness, betrayal, or ideological incoherence. This article examines the International's attitudes to war and peace as developed and espoused in the decades before 1914, and finds that the decisions of the constituent socialist parties in 1914 were understandable within this context. Socialists were not abandoning past ideals, but attempting to put them into practice. The circumstances of modern war, however, made traditional distinctions – between aggressor and defensive belligerents, and between ‘progressive’ and ‘reactionary’ nations – difficult to maintain. For some socialists, this meant that socialists of every country had a certain justification in rallying to their nation's defence. For Lenin and the Bolsheviks, however, if no capitalist country could be considered innocent, then all must be guilty.
Irish Socialist Republicanism, 1906–36, by Adrian Grant
April 2015
|
Journal article
|
The English Historical Review
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
Karl Marx: An Intellectual Biography (Trans. Bernard Heise) by Rolf Hosfeld. Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2013. 190pp., £18.00, ISBN 9 780857 457424
February 2015
|
Journal article
|
Political Studies Review
4408 Political Science, 44 Human Society
A Heavy Load: The American Civil Rights Movement and the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Movement
January 2015
|
Chapter
|
The Other Special Relationship
3601 Art History, Theory and Criticism, 36 Creative Arts and Writing, 16 Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions
Political Imprisonment and the Irish, 1912-1921
January 2015
|
Journal article
|
ENGLISH HISTORICAL REVIEW
Political Imprisonment and the Irish, 1912-1921
January 2015
|
Journal article
|
ENGLISH HISTORICAL REVIEW
Ulster Since 1600: Politics, Economy, and Society, ed. Liam Kennedy and Philip Ollerenshaw
August 2014
|
Journal article
|
The English Historical Review
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
Modernism and British Socialism, by Thomas Linehan
June 2014
|
Journal article
|
The English Historical Review
4303 Historical Studies, 43 History, Heritage and Archaeology
Terence O'Neill
September 2013
|
Book
Terence O'Neill came to power as Prime Minister of Northern Ireland in 1963 with a bold plan to 'literally transform the face of Ulster'. For the next six years O'Neill proved himself to be Stormont's most controversial leader. Though born of the gentry, he was determined to break from the past. Motorways replaced railways, a New City was planned, and a New University built. By meeting with Taoiseachs of the Irish republic, O'Neill intended no less than to end the long cross-border Cold War. Most audaciously, he worked to end the centuries old political divide between catholic and protestant, even if this meant plunging his own Ulster Unionist Party into crisis. O'Neill stirred up passion and anger. While many saw him as Ireland's great hope, Ian Paisley denounced him as a traitor and Unionist ministers plotted his downfall. When the civil rights movement took to the streets in 1968, O'Neill's response was prophetic: 'it is a short step from the throwing of paving stones to the laying of tombstones.'Confronted by demonstrations and counter-demonstrations, pressure from London and rebellion in his own party, O'Neill gambled all on in a bid to re-cast the very shape of politics in the province. When finally he was 'literally blown from office' in April 1969, in the midst of rioting and loyalist bombs, thirty years of violence had begun. Marc Mulholland's study of O'Neill argues for the centrality of O'Neill to modern Irish history. Based upon exhaustive research, it brings to focus a period when Northern Ireland really did stand at the crossroads.
Inventing the Working Class
January 2013
|
Internet publication
A Review Essay on Karl Marx
<a href=""></a>
Review Essay on 'The Republic: The Fight for Irish Independence, 1918-1923'
January 2013
|
Internet publication
<a href=""></a>
Bourgeois Liberty and the Politics of Fear: From Absolutism to Neo-Conservatism
October 2012
|
Book
In 1842, the German poet, Henrich Heine, wrote that the bourgeoisie, ‘obsessed by a nightmare apprehension of disaster’ and ‘an instinctive dread of communism’, were driven against their better instincts into tolerating absolutist government. Theirs was a ‘politics … motivated by fear’. Over the next 150 years, the middle classes were repeatedly accused by radicals of betraying liberty for fear of ‘red revolution’. The failure of the revolutions of 1848, conservative nationalism from the 1860s, fascist victories in the first half of the twentieth‐century, and repression of national liberation movements during the Cold War — these fateful disasters were all explained by the bourgeoisie’s fear of the masses. For their part, conservatives insisted that demagogues and fanatics exploited the desperation of the poor to subvert liberal revolutions, leading to anarchy and tyranny. Only evolutionary reform was enduring. From the 1970s, however, liberal revolution revived on an unprecedented scale. With the collapse of Communism, bourgeois liberty once again became a crusading, force, but now on a global scale. In the twenty-first century, the armed forces of the United States, Britain and NATO became instruments of ‘regime change’, seeking to destroy dictatorship and build free‐market democracies. President George W. Bush called the invasion of Iraq in 2003 a ‘watershed event in the global democratic revolution’. This was an extraordinary turn‐around, with the middle classes now hailed as the truly universal class which, in emancipating itself, emancipates all society. The debacle in Iraq, and the Great Recession from 2008, revealed all too clearly that hubris still invited nemesis.This book examines this remarkable story, and the fierce debates it occasioned. It takes in a span from the seventeenth century to the twenty‐first, covering a wide range of countries and thinkers.
History
'Just another country?': the Irish question in the Thatcher years
August 2012
|
Chapter
|
Making Thatcher's Britain
In their emblematic song of commercial nihilism, ‘Anarchy in the UK’ (1977), the Sex Pistols sarcastically reflected on the bathetic fate of that once imperial title, the ‘United Kingdom’. The UK was now little more than one acronym among many in a neo-corporate Britain straining under the weight of a proliferation – NEDDY, TUC, CBI, PIB, GLC, etc. Northern Ireland seemed only the most extreme example of a general dissolution, where Parliament and government waned in their effective power of decision and acronym organisations had taken on a life of their own:
Is this the M.P.L.A. or
Is this the U.D.A. or
Is this the I.R.A.
I thought it was the U.K.
Or just another country
For Conservatives, of course, punk was part of the disease. Northern Ireland, however, was in their eyes an extreme manifestation of a general malaise: the decline of parliamentary sovereignty, refusal to defend to the hilt irreducible Britishness, and conciliation of subversion and over-mighty interest groups. Indeed, by the later 1970s, it was close to common sense that Britain had made the situation in Northern Ireland worse by trying too hard to resolve it.
Bourgeois Liberty and the Politics of Fear
January 2012
|
Book
'Modernising Conservatism': The Northern Ireland Young Unionist Movement in the 1960s
February 2010
|
Journal article
|
Irish Political Studies
The origins of neo‐liberalism and neo‐conservatism may be found in the 1960s, when radical conservatives orientated towards the young and idealised the middle class as the primary agent of modernity. In Northern Ireland, a struggle for the soul of the Young Unionist Movement pitted a liberal anti‐sectarianism against a neo‐conservative belief in unionist destiny. The triumph of the latter contributed to the collapse of Ulster Unionist moral authority to govern the nationalist constituency of Northern Ireland.
'Its Patrimony, its Unique Wealth!' Labour-Power, Working-Class Consciousness and Crises: An Outline Consideration
January 2010
|
Journal article
|
Critique: a journal of socialist theory
This article follows on from a piece by the present author that attempted to explain why Marx thought that proletarians have a tendency towards socialist preference formation. My first intention here is to establish that the historical evidence of Marx's time and since lends weight to Marx's hypothesis that workers, due to their reliance upon labour-power as the form of subsistent property peculiar to their class, incline towards support for socialisation of their mode of subsistence. My second intention is to sketch the interaction over time of labour-power as a property-form and the imperatives of capital. Finally, I seek to understand capitalist crises in this context. The title borrows from Flora Tristan's Union ouvrière.
Marx, the Proletariat, and the 'Will to Socialism'
August 2009
|
Journal article
|
Critique: a journal of socialist theory
This article examines the development of Marx's thought in its attempt to explain why the proletariat as a class were historically inclined to accept socialist ideas. For Marx, socialist consciousness arises from an innate desire to secure one's mode of subsistence. Class consciousness always idealises independent proprietorship. This holds true for proletarians. However, as capitalism makes individual proprietorship impossible, only collective ownership appears to offer secure independence.
Irish Republican Politics and Violence before the Peace Process, 1968–1994
September 2007
|
Journal article
|
European Review of History
Analyses of the Provisional IRA in Northern Ireland tend to underplay the influence of political strategy in the 1970s, preferring to emphasise militarism. Similarly, the persistence of militarism in the 1980s is often obscured by the attention paid to a ‘new’ republican political orientation. This article seeks to draw attention to the IRA's evolving attitude to the ‘problem’ of Ulster unionism, and republicanism's various estimations of the likely efficacy of violence throughout the period. Republicanism is best understood as a deeply rooted working-class ethno-nationalist movement interacting closely with the other agents of the Northern Ireland conflict: constitutional nationalism, unionism and the British government. ‘Armed struggle’ became a declining asset for republicanism as it came to be seen less as a form of ‘popular guerrilla warfare’ and more as ‘terrorism’.
'Not a Historical but a Prospective Application'? The 1798 Rising as Recalled in the Irish Popular Press of 1898
February 2006
|
Chapter
|
The Ulster Crisis 1885-1922
Between 1885 and 1921 the question of Irish Home Rule became increasingly focused on the province of Ulster, and especially on Ulster Unionist responses to a Dublin parliament. This book explores the making of a specifically Ulster dimension to this crisis and its impact on Ulster politics. D. George Boyce and Alan O'Day also trace its outcome in the partition of Ireland and the establishment of a Home Rule parliament in Northern Ireland - an outcome which still has resonances today.
History
Why Did Unionists Discriminate?
January 2004
|
Chapter
|
From the United Irishmen to Twentieth-century Unionism: A Festschrift for A. T. Q. Stewart
Published in honour and celebration of the work of A. T. Q. Stewart on the occasion of his seventy-fifth birthday, the essays written for this book reflect the range and breadth of his interests.
Social Science
The Longest War: Northern Ireland's Troubled History
June 2002
|
Book
"The Troubles" in Northern Ireland have proved one of the most intractable conflicts in Europe since World War II, consistently attracting international attention, particularly from the United States. This exploration of the central issues and debates about Northern Ireland sets them in the historical context of hundreds of years of conflict. It tackles many questions, such as: What accounts for the perpetuation of ethnic and religious conflict in Ireland? Why has armed violence proven so hard to control? Who are the major figures and issues in the conflict? Can we expect more "Northern Irelands" in the future?
History
The ‘best and most forward-looking’ in Ulster unionism: the Unionist Society (est. 1942)
May 2002
|
Journal article
|
Irish Historical Studies
During the premiership of Captain Terence O’Neill, from 1963 to 1969, an inclusive, liberal unionism for the first time guided the policies of the Northern Ireland state. Liberal roots in the Unionist Party, however, were never deep, and liberal unionism was effectively destroyed by the onset of the ‘Troubles’. It was an ambiguous creed, more pro-British than anxious to conciliate Irish nationalism. Liberal unionism’s aversion to overt and offensive anti-Catholicism struck a chord with perhaps the majority of the Protestant population. However, it did not encourage a proactive stance; rather a passive reciprocation of nationalist ‘goodwill’, defined, in effect, as acquiescence. It was an ideology of comfortable superiority. This can be illustrated by the fate of the Unionist Society. Uniquely for any unionist organisation of the post-war era, this association has left all its records open for inspection. The weaknesses and strengths of liberal unionism over a thirty-year span can thus be elucidated by a case-study examination of the Unionist Society.
Northern Ireland at the Crossroads: Ulster Unionism in the O'Neill Years, 1960-69
April 2000
|
Book
Centred on the dramatic premiership of Terence O'Neill, Northern Ireland at the Crossroads examines the most hopeful decade for Ulster Unionism this century. O'Neill's bold ambition to reach out to catholics inspired optimism but also massive political instability. Though concerned with the drama and personalities of high politics, this book has much to say on popular attitudes in one of the world's most politicised societies. New light is shed on Paisleyism, discrimination and the civil rights movement.
Political Science
Assimilation versus Segregation: Unionist Strategy in the 1960s
January 2000
|
Journal article
|
Twentieth Century British History
After an eighty-year record of remarkable unity in the face of threats from Irish Nationalism, Ulster Unionism suddenly fragmented in the late 1960s. This has been explained by reference both to the fissile nature of the Unionist pan-class alliance and to fundamental divisions over identity. Though important, these were not new factors and were compatible with a high degree of organizational unity. What ruptured the movement was Terence O'Neill's ambition to draw Catholics into the Unionist alliance, even at the expense of alienating some Protestant traditionalists. Increasingly, assimilatory Unionism, dominant in the Civil Service and civil society, confronted segregatory Unionism ensconced in the structures of the Unionist Party. This strategic dichotomy reached a climax with vicious Unionist in-fighting during the 1969 Crossroads election. O'Neill's assimilation-ism ultimately collapsed both because it was unconvincing to the ranks of Ulster Unionism, and because it failed in its primary aim of making inroads into Catholic support. O'Neill underestlimated the tenacity of both traditional Unionism and traditional Nationalism
To Comfort Always - A History of Holywell Hospital, Antrim 1898-1998
January 1999
|
Book
'One of the most difficult hurdles': The struggle for recognition of the Northern Ireland Committee of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, 1958-1964
January 1997
|
Journal article
|
Saothar: journal of the Irish Labour History Society